O:

Open: Journal of Arts & Letters

HAL: Heuristic Algorithmic Library|O:JA&L Guides & Rubrics||O:JA&L’s Analytical Rubric for Haiku & Senryu|with a Submission Preparation Checklist

Jeff Streeby

August 22nd, 2026

Share:
HAL: Heuristic Algorithmic Library|O:JA&L Guides & Rubrics||O:JA&L’s Analytical Rubric for Haiku & Senryu|with a Submission Preparation Checklist
An O:JA&L Guide for Submitters

THE O:JA&L HAIKU & SENRYU ANALYTICAL RUBRIC

Click on the title to download this free PDF guide and its readiness checklist for submitters.

OPEN: Journal of Arts & Letters (O:JA&L) has adopted an objective but sensitive and nuanced set of criteria for the evaluation of haiku and senryu poetry which may serve as a guide for submitters in these and related categories of poetry. In the view of O:JA&L, an analytical rubric for evaluating or critiquing English-language haiku and senryu requires moving past the rigid constraint of the 5-7-5 syllable count. As legendary poet and translator Jane Reichhold famously championed, these short poems are built on discipline, structural balance, and intentional poetic mechanics rather than arbitrary rules. Reichhold’s groundbreaking "Phrase and Fragment Theory" and her expansive taxonomy of compositional tools form the structural and thematic backbone of this rubric. Notably, Reichhold viewed haiku and senryu as structurally identical "halves of the same apple," differentiated primarily by their core intent, tone, and focus. Submitters should keep in mind that other publications look to different authorities in the formulation of their acceptance criteria. Comments the rubric are invited.

KEY ANALYTICAL LENS: JANE REICHHOLD'S CORE TECHNIQUES



When utilizing this rubric to analyze a poem, evaluate which specific technical pivot from Jane Reichhold’s list of haiku techniques is driving the work:

  • Comparison: Highlighting how two seemingly different things in nature or human life share a hidden commonality.
  • Contrast: Placing two sharply opposing images side-by-side to illuminate a distinct tension or reality.
  • Association: Linking a natural phenomenon or human action to another via intuitive, emotional, or sensory connections.
  • Sense-Switching (Synesthesia): Expressing a sensory input through an entirely different sense (e.g., seeing a sound, smelling a color).
  • Sketch (Shasei): Capturing a raw, unembellished "slice of life" or natural scene exactly as it is experienced in real-time.

THE O:JA&L SUBMISSION READINESS CHECKLIST FOR HAIKU & SENRYU



O:JA&L offers this SUBMISSION READINESS CHECKLIST that seeks to transform the analytical rubric into an actionable editing tool. It is designed to help you catch technical red flags before editors see your work. Specialty haiku and senryu journals receive thousands of submissions that read like broken prose or greeting card verse. To stand out, treat this checklist as a rigorous, post-draft compliance review.

PHASE 1: STRUCTURAL INTEGRITY & ARCHITECTURE

  • Locate the Pivot: Can you point to the exact spot where the poem cuts (kireji) between a separate noun fragment and a grammatical phrase?
  • Break the Chain: Ensure the poem does not read as a single, continuous run-on sentence. If you remove lineation, it should not look like standard prose.
  • Ditch the Punctuation Crutch: Try removing all exclamation points, question marks, and excessive commas. Does the structural layout still create a natural internal pause on its own?

PHASE 2: JUXTAPOSITION & RESONANCE

  • Measure the Distance: Look closely at the relationship between your two main images. Are they too close (e.g., dark night / starry sky — stating the obvious)? Are they too far apart (e.g., from the windbreak / I forgot my car keys — confusing)?
  • Confirm the Spark: When the phrase and fragment collide, does it spark an internal shift, an unexpected connection, or a sudden "aha!" moment for the reader?
  • Identify the Technique: Which specific Jane Reichhold technique is driving the poem? (Can you clearly identify it as Comparison, Contrast, Association, Sense-Switching, or Pure Sketch)?

PHASE 3: DICTION & IMMEDIACY (THE "HERE & NOW")

  • Enforce the Present Tense: Scan every verb. Eliminate past tense verbs and minimize clunky, passive gerunds ending in -ing.
  • Strip the Ego: Remove personal pronouns (I, me, my, we) unless they are absolutely essential to a senryu's human interaction. Let the reader experience the moment directly.
  • Show, Don't Tell: Delete abstract emotional words (sad, beautiful, lonely, angry). Replace them with concrete, sensory objects that evoke those exact emotions.
  • Kill the Clichés: Circle your adjectives. If you see words like gentle breeze, silent snow, or autumn leaves, replace them with sharp, hyper-specific imagery.

PHASE 4: RHYTHM, SPACE & ECONOMY

  • Pass the One-Breath Rule: Read the poem aloud naturally. Did you stumble, run out of air, or find it awkward? It should require only a single, effortless breath.
  • Trash the Filler: Did you pad lines with extra words just to hit a 5-7-5 syllable count? Specialty editors overwhelmingly prefer concise, lightweight structures (typically 10–14 total syllables).
  • Trim to the Bone: Challenge every single word. If you remove a specific word and the core meaning of the poem remains intact, permanently cut that word.

PHASE 5: GENRE ALIGNMENT & MARKET TARGETING

  • Verify the Haiku Kigo: If submitting as a haiku, does the piece contain a clear, evocative seasonal anchor? Ensure it is a concrete element of nature, not just a vague concept.
  • Check the Senryu Bite: If submitting as a senryu, does it swap out nature to focus on human nature? Look for a sharp edge of humor, irony, psychology, or satire.
  • Read the Guidelines: Did you verify if the target journal prefers strict, traditional styling, or if they lean toward contemporary, experimental English-language forms?

Image:  Bakaneko & Nekomata (AI-assisted digital image) by O:JA&L staff creative. 2026. Public domain via Midjourney AI.

OJAL Art Incorporated, publishing since 2017 as OPEN: Journal of Arts & Letters (O:JA&L) and its imprints Buttonhook Press, HOT BUTTON PRESS Contemporary Issues, and HIGH BUTTON PRESS Contemporary Art, supports writers and artists worldwide.

The O:JA&L Free Presses Masters Series

The O:JA&L Free Presses Masters Series (from OPEN: Journal of Arts & Letters) gathers acclaimed writers for concise, downloadable chapbooks that pair fresh work with candid reflections on craft. Each installment—often framed by an interview with an associate editor—opens a window onto how masters of poetry, prose poetry, flash fiction, and related hybrid forms build voice, compression, and surprise. Designed as a reader’s invitation and a writer’s toolbox, the series celebrates literary art that moves fast, cuts deep, and lingers long after the last line.

Click on the titles below to explore or download the free PDF chapbooks.

Prose Poetry and Flash Discourse

The Buttonhook Press Masters Series:
Brian Clements on Prose Poetry
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto

The Buttonhook Press Masters Series:
Mark Budman on Flash Fiction & Nonfiction
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto

The Buttonhook Press Masters Series:
Ray Gonzalez on Prose Poetry
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto

The Buttonhook Press Master Series:
Michael Martone on Flash Fiction
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto

The Buttonhook Press Master Series:
Roberta Allen on Flash Fiction
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto

The Buttonhook Press Master Series:
Peter Conners on Flash Fiction
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto

The Buttonhook Press Masters Series:
Maxine Chernoff on Prose Poetry
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto

The Buttonhook Press Masters Series:
Pedro Ponce on Flash Fiction
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto

The Buttonhook Press Masters Series:
Kent Dixon on Flash Fiction & Nonfiction
With an interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto

The Buttonhook Press Masters Series:
Tom Hazuka on Flash Fiction
With an interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto

MIixed Forms: Haibun, Haiga, & Tanka Prose

The Buttonhook Press Masters Series:
Roberta Beary on Haibun
With an interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto

Experimental Discourse

The Buttonhook Press Masters Series:
Jim Meirose on Experimental Discourse
With an interview by Associate Editor Warwick Newnham

Poetry: All forms & styles

The Buttonhook Press Masters Series:
Poetry from Bruce McRae
With an Interview by Associate Editor Jeff Streeby

The Buttonhook Press Masters Series:
Poetry from Richard Widerkehr
With an Interview by Associate Editor Jeff Streeby

The Dally Post Press Masters Series:
Rod Miller on Cowboy Poetry
With an Interview by Associate Editor Jeff Streeby

More titles in press

  • editor's advice
  • editorial submissions rubrics
  • essay
  • literary arts
  • Nonfiction
  • performance arts
  • process analysis
  • submissions preparation checklists