O:JA&L FREE PRESSES|HAL: Heuristic Analysis Library|O:JA&L Guides & Rubrics||O:JA&L’s Analytical Rubric for Poetry on the Page

O:JA&L Guides & Rubrics
O:JA&L Editors’ Processes for Reviewing Submissions

O:JA&L’s POETRY EVALUATION RUBRIC is a tool for the training and calibration of new editors and screening readers of O:JA&L poetry submissions. Using O:JA&L’s POETRY EVALUATION RUBRIC, O:JAL editors evaluate each submission across six weighted categories totaling 100 points, with scores ranging from 1 to 5 per criterion (see scoring notes). A poem is considered for acceptance when it earns at least 88 points overall, provided no evaluative category receives a score of 0 and flawed language conventions do not trigger automatic rejection. The editors read holistically but score analytically, assessing how form, structure, diction, theme, imagery, and unity of impression work together. The “Evaluator’s Narrative” represents the evaluator’s balanced assessment of features. High scores are interpreted by editors as a reflection of the writer’s consistent control, purposeful deviation, and artistic mastery, signaling readiness for publication. Editors and screening readers use the rubric until it is internalized.
Written Poetry
ANALYSIS & EVALUATION RUBRIC
Click on the title above to download the compact version of the O:JA&L Evaluation Rubric.
This rubric supports consistent, evidence-based evaluation of written poetry across form, diction, theme, imagery, and unity of impression. Evaluators should consider each category independently, then judge how the poem’s choices interact. Descriptors identify threshold, proficient, and masterful achievement while leaving room for varied traditions, aesthetics, audiences, and artistic intentions.
Scoring note: Evaluate language conventions in relation to the work’s purpose, audience, genre, and aesthetic choices. Do not penalize nonstandard grammar, punctuation, spelling, dialect, code-switching, fragmentation, or syntactic disruption when these choices are purposeful, controlled, and effective.
Scoring note: This rubric uses a threshold scale rather than a continuous five-point scale. A score of 3 represents the minimum acceptable performance for a category. A score of 1 indicates performance below minimum expectations, while scores of 4 and 5 indicate increasing levels of proficiency and mastery. Because 3 is the threshold for acceptable performance, no score of 2 is used. To calculate weighted points, divide the category score by 5 and multiply by that category’s maximum value. The six weighted values total 100 points.
Unity of Impression
Final Scoring Note: This rubric is intended as a guiding instrument rather than a substitute for informed critical judgment. Evaluators should apply it consistently and transparently while recognizing that effective poems may succeed through varied traditions, forms, dialects, cultural contexts, experimental choices, and aesthetic purposes. Final scores and remarks should be based on observable evidence in the work, the writer’s apparent intentions, and the degree to which the poem’s choices create a coherent and meaningful artistic effect.
Image: Tobermory Peregestes (AI-assisted digital image) by O:JA&L staff creative. 2026. Public domain via Midjourney AI.
OJAL Art Incorporated, publishing since 2017 as OPEN: Journal of Arts & Letters (O:JA&L) and its imprints Buttonhook Press, HOT BUTTON PRESS Contemporary Issues, and HIGH BUTTON PRESS Contemporary Art, supports writers and artists worldwide.
BUTTONHOOK PRESS MASTERS SERIES
Click on the titles to explore or download the free PDF chapbooks.
The Buttonhook Press Masters Series: Brian Clements on Prose Poetry
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto
The Buttonhook Press Masters Series: Mark Budman on Flash Discourse
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto
The Buttonhook Press Masters Series: Ray Gonzalez on Prose Poetry
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto
The Buttonhook Press Master Series: Michael Martone on Flash Fiction
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto
The Buttonhook Press Master Series: Roberta Allen on Flash Fiction
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto
The Buttonhook Press Master Series: Peter Conners on Flash Fiction
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto
The Buttonhook Press Masters Series: Maxine Chernoff on Prose Poetry
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto
The Buttonhook Press Masters Series: Pedro Ponce on Flash Fiction
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto
The Buttonhook Press Masters Series: Tom Hazuka on Flash Fiction
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto
The Buttonhook Press Masters Series: Kent Dixon on Flash Fiction & Nonfiction
With an Interview by Associate Editor Pamelyn Casto
The Buttonhook Press Masters Series: Jim Meirose on Experimental Discourse
With an interview by Associate Editor Warwick Newnham
O:JA&L’S HIGH BUTTON PRESS ART CHAPBOOKS
Click on the titles to explore or download the free PDF chapbooks.
RITES OF CALIBRATION: Images & Excerpts
Fine Art Photography by Rex Wilder
Fine Art Photography by Natalie Christensen
Painting and drawing by Anne-Marie Brown
BY LAND AND BY SEA: Awakening the Sensual
Sculpture and Installation by Mark Yale Harris
Painting and drawing by Bette Ridgeway
Painting and drawing by Kathleen Frank
Painting and drawing by Catherine Eaton Skinner
Implications of Energy
Artist portfolio of Dr. Ernest Williams III

- Nonfiction
- literary arts
- editor's advice
- performance arts
- essay
- process analysis
- editorial submissions rubrics
- submissions preparation checklists
